Skip to content 
AITA for Not Rehoming My Daughter’s Cat for My Partner’s Allergic Son. I (38M) have a 12-year-old daughter who’s been through a lot. I have full custody of her, and her mom doesn’t see her because of serious reasons I can’t explain. We moved far from her old home, where she left behind a school and friends she loved. Her best friend also died recently from leukemia. It’s been really hard on her.
My partner (36M) and I want to live together. His 10-year-old son is allergic to cats, but my daughter’s cat has been her best friend for six years.
The cat has helped her a lot, especially after everything she’s lost. I’m worried that getting rid of the cat would hurt her mental health.
My partner says I need to get rid of the cat for his son. Since his son only visits every other weekend, I’ve offered to build an apartment above our garage for them to use during their visits or even rent a place for them while it’s being built.
My partner is upset about this idea. He thinks his son will feel left out and unwanted. I’ve tried to explain how important the cat is to my daughter, but we can’t agree.
Am I wrong for wanting to keep the cat?
Read more: Reddit
AITA for Not Rehoming My Daughter’s Cat for My Partner’s Allergic Son?
I (38M) have a 12-year-old daughter who’s been through a lot, including moving far from her old home and losing her best friend to leukemia. She has a cat she’s been close to for six years, which has comforted her.
My partner (36M) and I want to move in together, but his 10-year-old son is allergic to cats. My partner insists I need to get rid of the cat for his son, but since his son only visits every other weekend, I’ve offered to build a separate apartment for them or even rent a place.
My partner thinks this will make his son feel left out. I’ve tried to explain how much the cat means to my daughter, but we’re at a deadlock.
Am I wrong for wanting to keep the cat?
Let’s get into the top Comments: AITA for Not Rehoming My Daughter’s Cat for My Partner’s Allergic Son
How about not having your partner move in then? They aren’t being very sympathetic to your daughter, and it just seems like moving in together is a bad idea. At least while the cat is alive.
NTA, you offered a very fair compromise that would keep everyone healthy. Maybe not perfectly happy, but healthy. Be cautious around this person though. Your daughter is in a vulnerable place, and this person has proven they don’t care about that.
Bruh, if you get rid of that cat, your daughter will never forgive you, plain and simple. You have offered solutions, it’s up to your partner what he wants
NTA, that cat means a lot to her and for all you know this relationship may not last
Edit: Be careful, I wouldn’t be surprised if your partner tries to get rid of the cat. I’ve heard of it happening in situations similar to this on Reddit
NTA. He’s saying his son should be prioritized over your daughter who lives here fulltime now.
If he actually wants to intertwine his life with yours he needs to care about your kid; if he’s not willing to do that then it sounds like he’s not ready for that step.
You are absolutely NTA and under no circumstances should you get rid of that cat. If he keeps fighting over it break up with him. The cat and you are all your daughter has left now.
I also think you might want to delay moving in together with your partner for your daughters sake. She deserves to live with just you for a while.
Related Article:
