Skip to content 
AITA for Suggesting Our Baby Daughter Have Her Own Room? In their cozy two-bedroom home nestled in a quiet suburb, a couple in their late thirties lives happily with their adorable one-year-old daughter. Both work from home now, each enjoying their own little office space within the house.
Their peaceful home life recently hit a snag when they debated the best way to set up their space for their growing daughter. The wife, always thoughtful and caring, suggested turning her husband’s office into a fun playroom for their little girl. It seemed like a smart way to create a nurturing space without moving things around too much.
But the husband, thinking ahead and wanting to make the most of their space, proposed converting part of their spacious basement into a cozy bedroom for their daughter. The basement, though underground, gets plenty of natural light and is free from dampness or mold. It also has multiple exits, making it a safe choice.
The wife, however, had doubts. She wasn’t worried about safety or the basement’s condition; her concerns were more about keeping their daughter close to the main parts of the house. She felt a strong maternal instinct to have their child near the heart of their home.
As they work through this decision, the couple is at a standstill. Both ideas have their strengths and weaknesses, shaped by their unique needs and feelings. Their discussions show how much they care about creating the best environment for their daughter, even if they haven’t yet found a perfect solution.
Read More: REDDIT
AITA for Suggesting Our Baby Daughter Have Her Own Room?
Want More: Reddit Stories
Let’s swiftly assess a handful of the top comments: AITA for Suggesting Our Baby Daughter Have Her Own Room?
YTA.
I’d have a variety of safety concerns with this – being unable to hear her, whether she would be near dangerous items/hazards in a basement, and fire safety. If she’s sleeping on the same floor as you, it would be much easier to grab her from her room in the event of a fire, but in the basement, she could be trapped down there.
Also, she’s used to sleeping in your bedroom, so moving her to a different part of the house, and what is I assume is the scariest part of the house, may be really hard for her and/or not go well as this is a drastic change.
I’m sure you can still find other ways to enjoy the lake view.
Op, perfect solution. Why doesn’t your wife and daughter move to the basement. You’ll get the lake view all to yourself as well as the fresh air. You won’t have to hear your child cry at night or make noise. So you won’t feel like you have to take care of her. Bonus, you won’t have to listen to your wife snore or work either. It will be what you truly want, to be alone with your lake view. /s
You want to have your infant daughter sleep in the basement BECAUSE OF THE LAKE VIEW?
YTA.
Also, think about the practicalities of this. Do you really want to run into the basement every time she wakes up? Can’t you and your wife share a home office?
YTA
Put your office in the basement
I’d be very concerned about baby being on a different floor than your bedroom, or in a place in the house where she can’t be heard if something is wrong with your baby monitor.
Keeping a lake view for yourself and relegating your 1 year old to the basement is bad parenting.
YTA Why not put your office in the basement?
