AITAH telling girlfriend that she gave me the ‘ick’ at a family dinner?

I’m a 32-year-old man dating my 27-year-old girlfriend, Jenny, for almost a year. Jenny is an only child from an Asian family, while I’m mixed and have a younger sister, Anna, who is 21. Despite the age gap, Anna and I are very close because I often took care of her while our parents worked long hours.

Lately, Jenny has been making jokes about how Anna is spoiled and a “princess” because of how we treat her. At a recent family dinner, Jenny seemed to question Anna about her school and dating life.

When Anna shared a story about a date where the guy didn’t pay for the meal, Jenny laughed and said Anna should “lower her standards” because not every man will treat her like I do. I found this comment disrespectful and didn’t want to embarrass Jenny, but it upset me.

Jenny also compared this to her own experiences, saying men see her as “high value,” which further annoyed me. I told her that her comments were giving me “the ick” and asked her to stop talking about my sister that way.

Afterwards, we had a major argument. Jenny accused me of overreacting and said I’d be a terrible father because I would favor my sister. I’m shocked by her reaction and still feel I wasn’t wrong, but I’m looking for another perspective.

Read More: Reddit

Want More: Reddit Stories

A 32-year-old man named Mike has been dating his girlfriend, Jenny, who is 27, for almost a year. They have met each other’s families. Jenny is an only child from an Asian family, while Mike has a younger sister, Anna, who is 21. Mike and Anna are very close because he often took care of her due to their parents’ busy jobs.

Recently, Mike noticed Jenny making jokes about Anna being spoiled by their parents and Mike himself. Last week, during a family dinner, Jenny grilled Anna about her education, dating life, and plans.

Anna shared a story about a bad date when the guy didn’t pay for their meal, leaving her to cover the cost. Jenny laughed and said not every man would treat Anna like her brother and that she needed to lower her standards. Mike found this disrespectful but didn’t want to embarrass Jenny in front of his family.

Jenny then added that such a thing would never happen to her because men see her as “high value.” This comment made Mike angry. He told Jenny she was giving him “the ick” and to stop talking to his sister like that.

At home, the argument between Mike and Jenny escalated. Jenny accused Mike of overreacting and said he would be a terrible father because he would always favor his sister. This comment shocked Mike. He still feels he wasn’t wrong but wants another opinion.

Mike was right to defend his sister. Jenny’s comments were disrespectful and hurtful. The argument shows deeper issues in their relationship, especially about respect and understanding family dynamics. Jenny’s harsh comment about Mike being a terrible father suggests a significant difference in their views.

Respect and understanding are crucial in relationships, especially concerning family. While jokes are common, it’s important to know and respect boundaries. Communication is key. Addressing concerns calmly can prevent misunderstandings. Mike’s protective nature is good, but balancing this with maintaining relationship harmony is essential.

Let’s swiftly assess a handful of the top comments: AITAH telling girlfriend that she gave me the ‘ick’ at a family dinner?

NTA !!!! Its like she’s trying to compete with your sister. Id have already gotten rid of her.

I understand “high value” as a dog whistle for a certain internet celebrity that has been imprisoned in Romania for human trafficking.

NTA. She’s a walking red flag *Jennifer then went on talk about how that would’ve never happen to her as men see her as “high value”.* what is this comment ? ewwwwwww her behavior with your sister is sooo uncalled for, please run, this is not someone who you should settle down with .

it seems like her own “princess status” is threatened by your caring and close sibling relationship, so she is resorting to setting up a competition between her and your sister in order to punch-down on your sister to elevate her sense of ‘value’. Your gf is immature and not a nice person.