Skip to content 
Alex, a 32-year-old successful professional, is navigating a tricky family situation involving his younger brother, Tim, who is 28 and newly engaged to his fiancée, Lisa. Tim’s wedding plans are nothing short of extravagant, and he has approached Alex for a substantial financial contribution, knowing Alex’s financial stability and history of supporting family members.
The tension between the brothers surfaced during a family dinner when Tim made a hurtful remark about Alex and his wife Sarah’s wedding. He suggested that their modest celebration was inferior and implied that their wedding could have been more impressive if they had sought financial help. The comment struck a nerve with Sarah, who had poured her heart into planning their special day and felt deeply disrespected by Tim’s insinuation.
Feeling compelled to address the issue, Alex confronted Tim, asking him to apologize to Sarah for his insensitive comment. Tim, however, brushed off the complaint, claiming it was just a joke and accusing Alex and Sarah of overreacting. Despite Tim’s dismissive attitude, he continues to pressure Alex for the financial support he initially requested.
The situation is further complicated by the involvement of Alex’s parents, who have begun to subtly hint that Alex should contribute to Tim’s wedding to maintain family unity. They argue that Alex’s refusal could lead to a significant family rift, especially with Tim’s wedding fast approaching. The added pressure from their parents makes Alex’s decision even more fraught.
Adding another layer to the conflict, Alex has been dealing with mounting stress at work, making the family drama feel even more overwhelming. He’s torn between his desire to support his brother and his need to stand up for his wife, who feels unjustly criticized. Alex and Sarah are firm in their belief that an apology from Tim is necessary before any financial support is given.
As the wedding date looms closer, Alex finds himself at a crossroads, unsure if he’s making the right choice by withholding support until Tim acknowledges his mistake. The potential for a family rift weighs heavily on him, and he is seeking advice on whether his stance is reasonable or if he should reconsider in the interest of preserving family harmony.
Read More: REDDIT
Want More: Reddit Stories
Alex, a 32-year-old, faces a dilemma involving his younger brother, Tim, who is 28 and planning an extravagant wedding.
Tim asked Alex for significant financial support, but tension arose after Tim made a disparaging remark about Alex and his wife Sarah’s modest wedding, suggesting it was inferior and could have been better with financial help.
Sarah was hurt by Tim’s comment, and Alex confronted Tim, asking for an apology. Tim dismissed the issue, claiming it was just a joke. Despite this, he continues to pressure Alex for financial support. Alex’s parents are also urging him to contribute to avoid family discord.
Alex and Sarah believe Tim should apologize before any financial help is provided. With family pressures mounting and a potential rift on the horizon, Alex is unsure if his decision to withhold support until Tim apologizes is justified or if he should reconsider for the sake of family unity.
Let’s swiftly assess a handful of the top comments: AITA for Not Funding My Brother Wedding Because He Insulted My Wife?
DawnShakhar writes:
NTA. The inner circle of your family is you and your wife. Your first family duty is to her. Your brother insulted her, and he owes her an apology. No apology, no money. That simple. Tell him that his apology, sincerely and directly to Sarah is a condition of his receiving any financial contribution from the two of you.
And as for fancy weddings – we had the simplest of weddings. It was held in my parents’ living room. The food was made by family members. I wore an old dress that my husband loved. His aunt took a few photographs. The music was supplied by my father on the recorder, me on the guitar and the guests singing folk songs. It was a really joyous wedding. This year we will be celebrating our 40th anniversary with our children and grandchildren.
My cousin had the most lavish – and admittedly beautiful – wedding I’ve ever been to. Lovely venue (the wedding ceremony took place on a miniature island in an artificial lake), beautiful decorations, great food, the bride and bridesmaids in exquisite dresses. They were divorced within a year.
I thought it was just us – but it turns out to be a well-documented phenomenon: expensive weddings have a higher probability of ending in divorce.
So, you and your wife had a lovely and personalized wedding, that was funded by yourselves….but your brother, who didn’t contribute a dime towards yours, wants you to subsidize his “fairytale wedding”? Tell your brother that maybe if he kicked in some cash towards yours, you know, cause FAMILY, it could have been fancier and more up to his standards, but since he didn’t, he and his fiance can fund their own wedding and see how much that gets them. NTA, and I wouldn’t give him money even if he did apologize, because he’d only be doing it to get the money, not because he would believe he was wrong.
NTA. While family unity is important, it shouldn’t come at the cost of disrespecting your wife. Your brother needs to understand the impact of his words and take responsibility for his actions.
You’re a married man which means family unity includes and pretty much starts with your wife. Your brother doesn’t get to decide if her feelings were hurt or not, he does get to apologize if he wants your help. This is not a case of damned if you do damned if you don’t. Your wife is priority one until you have kids and then she moves to priority two. You are priority two. You both feel your wife was disrespected, well there is a reason for the saying don’t bite the hand that feeds.
Your parents don’t get an opinion, family union is you united with your wife. Your brother needs to apologize or let that fairy tale go for something more modest he funds himself. He is taking you and your financial help for granted. You didn’t want a big wedding, and trashing the wedding you had should also upset you, especially if it is crapping on your wife. It’s only a joke if everyone is laughing, if not everyone is laughing it’s bullying.
NTA but you will be if you don’t stand firm on your wife being respected.
Not-so-subtly declare that he should apologize “for the sake of family unity.”
Then add that your brother was actually correct, and you can’t lend the money because you need it to take your wife on a fairy tale vacation — you know, to make up for the wedding. Which your brother so helpfully pointed out wasn’t up to standard! You’re just agreeing with his comment, clearly? Why would he be upset with that?
Or he can agree that he was in the wrong and apologize.
