Skip to content 
AITA for Focusing on My New Family Instead of My Estranged Daughter? John is navigating a fraught family landscape after significant upheavals. Following the death of his son Isaac and his subsequent remarriage to Lucy, John’s relationship with his eldest daughter, Amy, deteriorated. Feeling abandoned by her father and hurt by his new family, Amy chose to live with her mother, Brenda, who was involved in an affair that contributed to John and Brenda’s divorce.
Years Later:
- A Difficult Return: When Brenda and her partner Jake faced legal troubles, Amy needed a place to stay. Despite her initial reluctance, she moved back into John’s home. However, tensions flared as Amy felt marginalized compared to John’s new family, particularly his stepdaughters Claudia and Rose. She was given a small guest room and felt excluded from family activities.
Conflict Highlights:
- Perceived Favoritism: Amy accused John of replacing her with Claudia and Rose, leading to a confrontation where John defended his actions by pointing to Amy’s earlier choice to distance herself from the family.
- Efforts at Reconciliation: Despite attempts to mend the rift through family therapy, the deep-seated resentments persisted.
The situation escalated when Amy revealed she was pregnant and chose to leave John’s home. John felt his decisions were justified, given Amy’s past estrangement. However, outside perspectives questioned whether John fully considered the emotional impact of Amy’s troubled upbringing and her psychological distress.
Key Points:
- John’s Perspective: He believed his focus on his new family was justified by Amy’s earlier decision to sever ties.
- Family Dynamics: John’s actions were seen by some as neglectful of Amy’s emotional needs and the trauma she had experienced.
This story highlights the complexities of navigating new family dynamics, reconciliation, and the impact of unresolved emotional wounds. It raises questions about how to balance the needs of a new family with those of a troubled past. It underscores the difficulties of addressing deep-rooted psychological issues amidst shifting family relationships.
AITA for Focusing on My New Family Instead of My Estranged Daughter?
Let’s swiftly assess a handful of the top comments: AITA for Focusing on My New Family Instead of My Estranged Daughter?
You’re Asian and she only pays for her extra snacks? Definitely NTA. She’s there because she has nowhere else to go and her exclusion from family activities stems from her rude and entitled behavior, not because you don’t want her there.Why NTA especially when they’re Asian? Most Asian cultures are collectivists and when you buy food, it’s to share with everybody. That she’s buying extra snacks only for herself and not to share with anyone/everyone in the household is downright rude.
NTA, she’s had 5 years to get over the teenage impulsive decision.
NTA. She made her decisions and these are the consequences. Has she ever apologised for what she did? If she wants things to improve that would be a start.
If I’m reading this right… Amy wrote yall off at 16, and now 5 years later at 21yo has lost everything and is moving back because she has nowhere else to go? And you have been treating her as less than ever since?
Info:are you charging her rent? Does she have a job? What is the long term goal? It sounds like she isn’t quite a family member, but not quite a tenant either? She just exists in a home where she has to buy her own snacks?
