Skip to content 
AITA to Favor My New Family Over My Reconnected Daughter? In this complex family dynamic, a 26-year-old man found himself in a heated dispute with his 28-year-old sister, Emma, who recently faced both emotional and physical challenges.
Emma’s relationship with their parents, especially their mother, had always been fraught. During her college years, she developed a close bond with her creative writing professor, who became a surrogate mother figure to her. This deep connection further strained Emma’s already tenuous relationship with her mother.
Tragedy struck when Emma’s beloved professor unexpectedly passed away, leaving her heartbroken.
In her distress, Emma accidentally burned her arm with boiling water upon hearing the news. The burn became a painful physical reminder of her loss. To cope, Emma decided to cover the burn with a tattoo, choosing a design representing the flowers her professor had often given her. This tattoo was intended to be a lasting tribute to their bond.
Concerned about how their mother would react, the 26-year-old brother voiced his concerns, suggesting that the tattoo might be seen as hurtful and insensitive.
He felt it could be a painful reminder of their mother’s strained relationship with Emma and the symbolic replacement of her maternal role. Emma, however, felt her brother was overstepping and lashed out, ending the call abruptly. Emma refused to revisit the topic because the siblings’ relationship became strained.
Tensions within the family remain high. While agreeing with the brother’s concerns, the father advised him to stay quiet, whereas their mother, while appreciating his defense, remained silent on the matter.
This situation underscores the intricate dynamics of family relationships, where personal grief and long-standing emotional conflicts intertwine.
Read More: REDDIT
AITA to Favor My New Family Over My Reconnected Daughter?
Want More: Reddit Stories
A 26-year-old man clashed with his 28-year-old sister, Emma, after she decided to get a tattoo over a burn on her arm. The burn was from spilling boiling water when she learned that her beloved college professor had passed away.
The professor had been like a mother to Emma, straining her relationship with their actual mother. The brothers worried that the tattoo, a tribute to the professor, would hurt their mother’s feelings.
Emma accused him of overstepping, leading to a rift between them. Their father advised the brother to stay silent, while their mother appreciated his concern but remained silent.
The situation highlights the complexity of family dynamics and the intersection of grief and long-standing emotional issues.
pharoah4187 writes:
Yes. YTA.
For starters… your sister’s body belongs to her. You do not have a say in what goes on it. You can approve or disprove all you like, but it’s her decision.
For second… you are not the arbitrator of your mother and your sister’s relationship. If your sister is bothering your mother, it is not your place to fix that rift. If you mother is bothering your sister, it is not your place to fix that rift.
You sister lost a very close friend and person in her life and would like to get a meaningful tattoo to represent that relationship and honor that loss. There is no cruelty in that tattoo. There is only cruelty in the minds of people who think it’s somehow about them when it is not in ANY way.
StAlvis writes:
INFO
My mom was so embarrassed that day because she didn’t get N flowers
Why the hell are you so concerned about protecting this woman’s feelings?
MikeNoble91 writes:YTA. Its OK if you and your sister have different relationships with your mom. Trying to make your sister see your mom.just like you do is not going to work.
lihzee writes:YTA. Mind your business. Your mom being embarrassed because she forgot to buy her daughter flowers is her own damn problem. We can all tell you were mommy’s golden child from this post. Your poor sister.
ResoluteMuse writes:
What you have described is the golden child and the scapegoat child. You being the golden child. N didn’t get what she needed from her own mother and was incredibly fortunate that another stepped in and took on that role.
Take your blinders off and see. Ask your sister if she felt second best growing up, and be open (and silent) when, and to what, she tells you.
Yes. YTA
Edit: So many scapegoats checking in. Many hugs to you all.
